July 8, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Response to Respondent's Motion for Continuance of the Start of Trial or Sanctions Precluding Complaint Counsel's Presentation of a Rebuttal Case (45.13 KB) Complaint Counsel's Motion for Sanctions for Respondent's Willful Non-complliance with Orders that it Complete its Response to Complaint Counsel's First Request for Production of Documents and Things (1.07 MB) Commission Order Withdrawing Matter from Adjudication for the Purpose of Considering a Proposed Consent Agreement (13.93 KB)
July 3, 2002 Notice of Appearance Filed by Mark L. Kovner; James M. Koukios and Dileen D. Barish (Kirkland & Ellis) on Behalf of MSC.Software Corporation (40.23 KB) Respondent MSC.Sortware Corp.'s Motion for and Expedited Response to MSC's Emergency Motion for COntinuance of the Start of Trial or Sanctions Precluding Complaint Counsel's Presentation of a Rebuttal Case (95.12 KB) Third Party Lockheed Martin Corp.'s Supplemental Motion for In Camera Treatment of Designated Hearing Exhibits (109.01 KB) Order on MSC's Motion for Leave to File Corrected Versions (8.47 KB) Modifications to Scheduling Order (6.49 KB)
July 2, 2002 MSC.Software Corporation's Motion for Leave to File an Amended Motion Requesting In Camera Treatment of Certain Highly Confidential Documents (3.41 MB) MSC.Software's Opposition to Complaint Counsel's Motion In Limine to Exclude Evidence of Dassault as a Competitor (1002.56 KB) MSC.Software's Opposition to Complaint Counsel's Motion In Limine to Exclude Evidence of Efficiencies (333.53 KB)
July 1, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Opposition to Respondent MSC.Software's Motion In Limine to Limit Opinions of Complaint Counsel's Expert Witnesses (279.24 KB) Complaint Counsel's Opposition to Respondent MSC.Software's Motion In Limine to Exclude Investigational Hearing Transcripts (582.27 KB) MSC.Software Corporation's Proposed Findings of Fact (5.52 MB) Notice of Appearance (49.11 KB) Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Pre-Trial Brief and Proposed Conclusions of Law (4.12 MB) Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Supplemental Deposition Designations (127.42 KB)
June 28, 2002 Motion for Interim Relief on Advance Notice of Witness Order (195.23 KB) Third Party United Technology Corporation's Motion for In Camera Treatment of Documents (506.68 KB)
June 25, 2002 Order Amending Scheduling Order (8.13 KB) Complaint Counsel's Application for the Issuance of Subpoenas and Testificandum (879.67 KB) MSC's Notice of Withdrawal of its Motion to Remedy Jim Cashman's Refusal to Appear to His Deposition as Moot (74.58 KB) Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Motion Requesting In Camera Treatment of Certain Highly Confidential Business Documents (2.82 MB)
June 24, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Unopposed Motion to Extend Time for Filing its Responses to Respondent's Motions in Limine (74.66 KB) MSC.Software Corporation's and Complaint Counsel's Joint Motion to Amend the Second Revised Scheduling Order (92.96 KB) MSC.Software Corporation's Motion to Amend the Second Revised Scheduling Order (88.87 KB) MSC.Software Corporation's Reply Addressing Key Misrepresentation By Complaint Counsel on Seven-Day Advance Notice Issue and Integrated Motion for Leave to Reply (95.27 KB) Motion of Third-Party IBM for Leave to File Reply to MSC.Software Corporation's Response to Third-Parties' Application for In Camera Treatment (286.77 KB) Order Designating Administrative Law Judge (21.85 KB) Order Extending Time for Filing Complaint Counsel's Responses to Respondent's Motions in Limine (28.26 KB)
June 21, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Pretrial Proposed Findings of Fact (1.03 MB) Third Party Cessna Aircraft Corporation's Motion for Additional Extension of Time to File Motion for In Camera Treatment of Designated Hearing Exhibits (37.68 KB) The Boeing Company's Motion for In Camera Treatment of Certain Boeing Confidential and Property Information and Memorandum in Support Thereof (950.94 KB) Third Party Schaeffer Automated Simulations' Opposition to MSC's Motion to Reopen Dr. Schaeffer Deposition For a Limited Purpose (135.91 KB) Third Party Lockheed Martin Corporation's Motion for In Camera Treatment of Designated Hearing Exhibits and Memorandum in Support Thereof (221.34 KB) Notice of Appearance filed by Perkins Coie LLP on Behalf of the Boeing Company (21.94 KB)
June 20, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Opposition to Respondent's Motion Seeking Extension of the Date for Filing Its Pretrial Brief, Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (58.15 KB) Complaint Counsel's Pretrial Brief (444.63 KB) Order on MSC's Motion for Extension of Time (9.56 KB)
June 19, 2002 Respondent MSC.Software Corp.'s Motion Seeking An Extension to the Filing Date for Pretrial Brief, Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (89.85 KB) MSC.Software Corporation's Motion for Leave to File a Corrected Version of Its Motion for Extension of Time to Seek In Camera Treatment for Propose Trail Exhibits (49.38 KB) Order Regarding MSC's Motion for Extension of Time (9.21 KB) Order Granting Respondent MSC.Software Corp.'s Motion for Extension of Time to Seek In Camera Treatment for Proposed Trial Exhibits (7.99 KB) Order Granting United Technologies Corp.'s Unopposed Motion for a Further Extension of Time to Seek In Camera Treatment of Documents (9.38 KB) Order Granting MSC's Motion for Leave to File a Corrected Version of Its Motion for Extension of Time to Seek In Camera Treatment and MSC's Motion for Extension of Time (9.21 KB) MSC.Software Corp.'s Response to Third-Parties' Application for In Camera Treatment (48.62 KB) Complaint Counsel's Response to Respondent MSC.Software Motion for Seven Day Advance Notice of Witness Order (40.13 KB) Ansys Inc.'s Response to MSC's Supplement to Its Emergency Notion to Remedy Jim Cashman's Refusal to Appear for His Deposition and Motion to Reopen Dr.Schadffer's Deposition for a Limited Purpose (73.53 KB)
June 18, 2002 Third-Party Nibbitt, Karlsson & Sorensen, Inc.'s Motion for In Camera Treatment of Certain Documents Identified on Exhibit Lists of Complaint Counsel and MSC.Software Corp. (236.57 KB)
June 17, 2002 Respondent MSC.Software's Notice of Third Party Requests for In Camera Treatment of Proposed Trial Exhibits (61.78 KB) MSC's Supplement to Its Emergency Motion to Remedy Jim Cashman's Refusal to Appear for His Deposition and Motion to Reopen Dr. Schaeffer's Deposition for a Limited Purpose (207.53 KB) Respondent MSC.Software Corp.'s Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Seek In Camera Treatment for Proposed Trial Exhibits (38.83 KB) Respondent MSC.Software's Motion for Seven Day Advance Notice of Witness Order (94.82 KB) Respondent MSC.Software's Motion In Limine to Preclude Complaint Counsel's Expert Witnesses From Testifying About Opinions Not Previously Disclosed to MSC (365.21 KB) Respondent MSC.Software Corp.'s Reply to Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel Respondent to Complete Its Response to Complaint Counsel's First Request for Production of Documents and Things (50.61 KB) Respondent MSC.Software's Motion In LImine to Exclude Use of Inadmissible Part II Investigatory Hearing Transcripts By Complaint Counsel and Its Expert Witness (235.94 KB) United Technologies Corporation's Unopposed Motion for a Further Extension of Time to Seek In Camera Treatment of Documents (43.13 KB)
June 14, 2002 Dr. Rakesh Allahabadi's Motion for Extension of Time to File a Motion Requesting In Camera Treatment (17.33 KB) Complaint Counsel's Pre-Trial Proposed Conclusions of Law (536.31 KB)
June 13, 2002 Response of Complaint Counsel to MSC's "Emergency" Motion Regarding the Cashman Deposition and MSC's Unopposed Notion to Amend the Revised Scheduling Order (93.13 KB)
June 12, 2002 Order Granting Third Party Cessna Aircraft Corp.'s Motion for Extension of Time to File Motion For In Camera Treatment of Designated Hearing Exhibits (9.29 KB) Order Granting Motion of Third Party Hibbitt, Karlsson & Sorensen, Inc. to Extended Time to File Motion for In Camera Treatment of Hearing Exhibits (9.32 KB) Modifications to Scheduling Order (16.3 KB) Order on Dr.Rakesh Allahabadi's Motion for Extension to Seek In Camera Treatment of Documents (8.75 KB) Order on Freightliner LLC's Motion for Extension to Seek In Camera Treatment of Documents (9.17 KB)
June 11, 2002 Third Party Cessna Aircraft Corporation's Motion for Extension of Time to File Motion for In Camera Treatment of Designated Hearing Exhibits (34.11 KB) Notice of Appearance Filed by Shearman & Sterling on Behalf of Dassault Systems (12.88 KB) Dassault System's Motion for In Camera Order (206.24 KB) Order Modifying Certain Pre-Trial Dates Set Forth in The Second Revised Scheduling Order (13.86 KB) ANSYS, Inc.'s Response to MSC's Emergency Motion to Remedy Jim Cashman's Refusal to Appear for His Deposition (107.56 KB) Third Party ANSYS, Inc.'s Application for IN Camera Treatment of Certain Trial Exhibits Sought to Be Introduced By Respondent And/Or Complaint Counsel (353.42 KB) Request of Daratech, Inc. for In Camera Treatment and Memorandum In Support Thereof (252.28 KB) Motion of Third Party IBM for IN Camera Treatment of Certain Highly Confidential Business Documents (208.93 KB) Bath Iron Works Unopposed Motion to Obtain IN Camera Treatment of Certain Highrtly Confidential Information (432.78 KB) Third Party Schaeffer Automated Simulation's Application for In Camera Treatment of Certain Trial Exhibits Sought to Be Introduced By Respondent And/Or Complaint Counsel (155.11 KB) Third-Party Hibbitt, Karlsson & Sorensen, Inc.'s Motion to Extend Tie to File Motion for In Camera Treatment of Hearing Exhibits (155.11 KB) Altair Engineering, Inc.'s Motion for In Camera Treatment of Certain Documents (90.02 KB)
June 10, 2002 Notice of Appearance Filed by Perkins Coie LLP on Behalf of Third Party the Boeing Company (9.57 KB) The Boeing Company's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Motion for In Camera Treatment of Certain Boeing Confidential and Proprietary Information (44.69 KB) Assented- to Motion by Raytheon Company to Extend Time to Move for In Camera Treatment of Proposed Trial Exhibits (36.92 KB) Complaint Counsel's Motion to Modify Certain Dates in Second Revised Scheduling Order (38.17 KB) Order Granting Third Party Lockheed Martin Corporation's Motion for Extension of Time to File Motion for In Camera Treatment of Designated Hearing Exhibits (10.1 KB) Order on Raytheon's Motion for Extension of Time (8.09 KB) Order Granting Respondent MSC.Software Corp.'s Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Seek In Camera Treatment for Proposed Trial Exhibits (8.53 KB) Order on the Boeing Company's Motion for Extension to File Motion for In Camera Treatment (9.48 KB) MSC's Emergency Motion to Remedy Jim Cashman's Refusal to Appear for His Deposition (347.08 KB) MSC.Software Corporation's Unopposed Motion to Amend the Revised Scheduling Order (72.49 KB)
June 7, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel Respondent to Respond On An Expedited Basis to This Motion and to Complete Its Response to Complaint Counsel's First Request for Production of Documents and Things (545.74 KB) Respondent MSC.Software Corp.'s Unopposed Motion For Extension of Time to Seek In Camera Treatment for Proposed Trial Exhibits (36.55 KB)
June 6, 2002 Third Party Lockheed Martin Corporation's Motion for Extension of Time to File Motion For In Camera Treatment of Designated Hearings Exhibits (40.8 KB)
June 5, 2002 Order Granting United Technologies Corporation's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Seek In Camera Treatment of Documents (9.41 KB)
June 4, 2002 United Technologies Corporation's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Seek In Camera Treatment of Documents (64.59 KB)
May 28, 2002 Third Party Harry Schaeffer's Motion for Leave to File Supplemental Affidavits (96.89 KB)
May 24, 2002 MSC's Motion for Leave to File Declaration of Colin R. Kass in Response to Third-Party Harry Schaeffer's Supplemental Affidavits and in Further Support of MSC's Opposition to Harry Schaeffer's Motion to Quash Deposition Subpoena (63.31 KB)
May 23, 2002 Third Party Harry Schaeffer's Motion to Quash Subpoena Served by MSC Software Corporation (190.35 KB) Complaint Counsel's Memorandum in Support of Third Party Harry Schaeffer's Motion to Quash Subpoena (31.93 KB) MSC's Opposition to Harry Schaeffer's Motion to Quash Deposition Subpoena (444.36 KB)
May 22, 2002 Order on Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel An Expedited Answer and Compliance with Complaint Counsel's First Request for Production of Documents and Things (23.18 KB)
May 21, 2002 Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Opposition to Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel an Expedited Answer to This Motion and Compliance Counsel's First Request for Production of Documents and Things (187.92 KB)
May 10, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel An Expedited Answer to This Motion and Compliance With Complaint Counsel's First Request for Production of Documents and Things (495.04 KB)
May 9, 2002 Withdrawal of Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel Compliance With Complaint Counsel's First Request for Production of Documents and Things (23.33 KB) Order Granting Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Motions For the Issuance of Subpoenas Duces Tecum and Ad Testificadum to the Department of Defense and to the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (73 KB) Order on Withdrawn Motions (9.52 KB)
May 8, 2002 Order Denying Motion for Protective Order and Granting Motion to Compel Depositions. (60.23 KB)
May 7, 2002 Order Denying Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Motion to Compel Production of Third-Party Transcripts. (92.74 KB)
May 3, 2002 Second Revised Scheduling Order. (58.52 KB) Complaint Counsel's Opposition to Respondent's Motions for Protective Order Regarding Complaint Counsel's Subpoenas for Testimony from MSC's Senior Executives and the Former CEO of CSAR. (51.91 KB)
May 2, 2002 Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Opposition to Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel Depositions. (42.28 KB)
May 1, 2002 Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Request for Leave to File a Supplemental Memorandum in Support of Its Motion to Amend the Scheduling Order. (252.9 KB) Complaint Counsel's Response to Respondent's Motion for A Second Amended Scheduling Order. (85.14 KB) Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel Depositions and to Shorten the Time for Responding to This Motion. (105.16 KB) Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Motion for Protective Order. (59.38 KB)
April 30, 2002 Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Withdrawal of Motion for Protective Order. (235.38 KB) Respondent's Reply Brief in Support of MSC's Motion to Amend the Scheduling Order. (236.57 KB) Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Motion for Proective Order. (235.38 KB)
April 26, 2002 Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Motion to Amend Trial Schedule. (152.38 KB) Complaint Counsel's Opposition to Respondent's Motion for a Second Amended Scheduling Order. (684.84 KB)
April 25, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Response to MSC's Motions for Subpoenas to the National Aeronautics and Space Administration and the Department of Defense. (131.73 KB)
April 16, 2002 Respondent MSC.Software's Motion & Memorandum in Support of Its Motion for the Issuance of Subpeonas Duces Tecum and Ad Testificandum to the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. (274.34 KB) Respondent MSC.Software's Motion In Support of Its Motion for the Issuance of Subpoenas Duces Tecum and AD Testificandum to the Department of Defense. (274.34 KB)
April 9, 2002 MSC.Software's Response to Motion of Daimlerchrysler Corp. to Limit Subpoena Duces Tecum. (21.45 KB)
March 29, 2002 Notice of Appearance Filed by Joshua B. Gray, Esq. of Axinn, Veltrop & Harkrider LLP, Counsel for MSC.Software Corp. (23.57 KB)
March 28, 2002 Order Granting Motion to Extend Time. (8.94 KB) MSC.Software Corporation's Stipulation. (23.12 KB)
March 27, 2002 MSC.Software Corporation's Supplemental Filing on PTC's Motion to Quash in Light of Recent Discussions. (108.55 KB)
March 18, 2002 MSC.Software's Response to Third-Party HKS' Motion to Extend Time to Limit Or Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum. (29.29 KB) Assented-To Motion to Extend MSC's Time to Oppose Third-Party Lear Corporation's Motion to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum. (45.19 KB)
March 15, 2002 Notice of Appearance and Motion to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum Filed by Michael J. Laramie of Bodman, Longley & Dahling LLP, Counsel for Third Party Lear Corporation. (60.2 KB)
March 5, 2002 Revised Scheduling Order. (51.49 KB) Order on Respondent MSC's Motion to Extend Trial Date. (71.3 KB)
March 4, 2002 MSC's Response to Parametric Technology Corporation's Motion to Limit or Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum. (342.66 KB) Assented to Motion to Extend MSC's Time to Oppose Third-Party Hibbitt, Karlsson & Sorensen's Motion to Extend Time to Move to Quash or Limit, or Comply with, Subpoena Duces Tecum Served by MSC Software Corporation. (39.61 KB)
March 1, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Withdrawal of Emergency Motion. (14.95 KB) Complaint Counsel's Opposition to Respondent MSC's Motion for Protective Order. (424.74 KB)
February 27, 2002 MSC Corporation's Withdrawal of Motion for Leave for In Camera Treatment of MSC's Revised Opposition to Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel Compliance to First Request for Documents and Things and MSC's Motion for Protective Order. (26.36 KB)
February 25, 2002 Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Request for Leave to File Second Supplemental Memorandum in Support in its Motion to Compel. (891.04 KB)
February 22, 2002 Third-Party Hibbitt, Karlsson & Sorensen, Inc.'s Motion to Extend Time to Move to Quash or Limit, or Comply With, Subpoena Duces Tecum Served by MSC Software Corporation. (385.55 KB)
February 21, 2002 Order on Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Motion to Compel Responses to Written Discovery. (132.32 KB)
February 20, 2002 Notice of Appearance (40.12 KB) MSC.Software Corporation's Motion for Leave for In Camera Treatment of MSC's Revised Opposition to Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel Compliance with First Request For Documents and Things and MSC's Motion for Protective Order. (694.61 KB)
February 8, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Request for Leave to File Supplemental Memorandum in Opposition to Motion to Compel (44.14 KB)
February 5, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Memorandum in Opposition to Respondent's Motion to Compel (293.7 KB) Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel Compliance With Complaint Counsel's First Request for Production Documents and Things (1.32 MB)
February 1, 2002 Correction to Public Version of Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Memorandum in Support of Its Motion to Compel Complaint Counsel to Respond to Written Discovery (186.64 KB)
January 31, 2002 Ansys, Inc.'s Motion to File the Attached Reply in Further Support of Its Motion to Limit MSC's Subpoena Duces Tecum (145.48 KB) Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Motion to Compel Complaint Counsel to Respond to Written Discovery (1.44 MB) Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Supplemental Memoradum in Support of Its Motion to Compel (Based Upon Complaint Counsel's Related "Revised" Amended Interrogatory Answers) (208.73 KB)
January 22, 2002 Complaint Counsel's Emergency Motion to Compel Compliance with Discovery Orders (97.57 KB) MSC.Software Corporation's Response to Complaint Counsel's Emergency Motion (104.49 KB)
January 18, 2002 Respondent MSC.Software Corporation's Memorandum in Opposition to Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel Compliance with Subpoenas (1.69 MB) Third-Party Ansys, Inc.'s motion to Limit Subpoena Duces Tecum Served by MSC.Software Corporation (1.27 MB) Order on Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel Compliance with First Document Request (16.71 KB) Order on Motion Relating to Eight Subpoenas Ad Testificandum and Duces Tecum Served by Complaint Counsel (40.45 KB)
January 14, 2002 Complaint Counsel's (MSC.Softwware Corporation) response to respondent's memorandum in opposition to complaint counsel's motion to compel compliance with complaint counsel's first request for production of documents and things (443.38 KB) Order on Ansys's Motion for extension of time (14.6 KB)
January 11, 2002 Second supplement to complaint counsel's motion to compel compliance with Subpoenas Ad Testificandum and Duces Tecum (216.45 KB)
January 7, 2002 MSC's response to ansys's motion for an extension of time to either respond or move to quash Subpoena Duces Tecum (1004.07 KB)
December 28, 2001 Third-Party Ansys, Inc.'s motion to extend time to respond and/or move to limit or quash Subpoena Duces Tecum served by MSC.Software Corporation (385.53 KB)
December 27, 2001 Complaint Counsel's motion to compel compliance with Complaint Counsel's frist request for production documents and things (1.04 MB) MSC.Software Corporation's opposition to Complaint Counsel's motion to compel compliance with Subpoenas AD Testificandum and Duces Tecum (79.32 KB)
December 17, 2001 Complaint Counsel's Response to Respondent MSC.Software Corp.'s Motion to Quash Subpoenas Ad Testificandum, and Complaint Counsel's Motion to Compel Compliance with Subpoenas Ad Testificandum and Duces Tecum (1.56 MB)
December 6, 2001 Joint Motion to Amend Protective Order Governing Discovery Material (302.12 KB) Amended Protective Order Governing Discovery Material (278.19 KB) Order Granting Joint Motion to Amend Protective Order Governing Discovery Material (9.2 KB)
December 5, 2001 MSC.Software Corporation's Motion to Quash Subpoenas Ad Testificandum Served by the Federal Trade Commission (359.22 KB)
October 10, 2001 Order Designating Administrative Law Judge (37.96 KB) PRESS RELEASE: FTC Challenges MSC.Software's Acquisitionsof Its Two Nastran Competitors
October 10, 2001 Administrative Complaint (35.19 KB) PRESS RELEASE: FTC Challenges MSC.Software's Acquisitionsof Its Two Nastran Competitors