When a major retailer declares bankruptcy, it can be a devastating day. But what about the mounds of customer information the company has compiled over the years? When a company closes its doors, what effect does bankruptcy have on a business’ privacy promises?
Director Vladeck wrote, “The representations Borders made to its customers about the privacy of their information, including email addresses and purchase history, would likely be considered very important to many customers. In particular, information about the types of books and videos customers have purchased would be considered personal to many customers. Consumers who bought such items would likely be very concerned if their information were to be transferred without restriction to an unknown purchaser for unknown uses.”
“We understand that Borders’ customer information constitutes a potentially valuable estate asset,” the letter continued. “We are concerned, however, that any sale or transfer of the personal information of Borders’ customers would contravene Borders’ express promise not to disclose such information and could constitute a deceptive or unfair practice.”
Director Vladeck continued, “it would be appropriate for Borders to obtain express consent from its customers, specifying the potential purchaser, before it transfers the data. The consent process would allow customers to make their own determination as to whether a transfer of their information would be acceptable to them. For consumers who did not consent, their data would be purged.”
But what if the bankruptcy court “declines to require consent to the transfer in light of other considerations”? The letter points to the settlement regarding the bankruptcy of toy retailer Toysmart as an appropriate model. “As in Toysmart, our concerns about the transfer of customer information inconsistent with privacy promises would be greatly diminished if all the following conditions were met:
- Borders agrees not to sell the customer information as a standalone asset;
- The buyer is engaged in substantially the same lines of business as Borders;
- The buyer agrees to obtain affirmative consent from consumers for any material changes to the policy that affect information collected under the Borders’ policy.”
Read the full letter here.