1206001 Informal Interpretation

Michael Verne

  – See Comments. 
K Walsh concurs.





Monday, June 11, 2012 4:34 PM


Verne, B. Michael; Walsh, Kathryn


Size-of-transaction question


Iam looking into a transaction, and hoping that you can assist with a few questionsthat I have. Our client, LLC 1 is contemplating a merger whereby itssubsidiary(s) will form one or more wholly-owned subsidiaries to merge with andinto Targets A, Band C, which are currently controlled by Entity X. LLC 1 is aprivate company, and its UPE is currently Entity Y. In consideration for themergers, LLC 1 will issue new equity to Entity X (or an entity affiliated withEntity X). Following the mergers, Entity Y will lose control of LLC 1. It isanticipated that no member of LLC 1 will have 50% or more of the rights toprofits, or assets upon liquidation, of LLC 1. The purchase agreement ascurrently contemplated does not include a determined acquisition price for theequity of Targets A, Band C, nor a stated value for the LLC 1 equity thatEntity X will receive.

Underan alternate scenario, Entity X (or an entity affiliated with Entity X), mayacquire 50% or more of the equity in LLC 1 in consideration for the mergers asdescribed above. It is still anticipated that Entity Y would have less than 50%of the rights to profits, or assets upon liquidation, of LLC 1 post-mergers.

Inaddition, debt of LLC 1's subsidiaries and of Targets A, Band C will berefinanced in connection with the mergers, such that the old debt of LLC 1'ssubsidiaries and of Targets A, Band C will be paid off in cash and new debtwill be taken on jointly and severally by LLC 1's subsidiaries and Targets A,Band C. A portion of the debt of LLC's subsidiaries being paid off in cash isheld by Entity Y.

Couldyou please confirm our understanding with regard to each of the following:

1-Under the first scenario (where Entity X is theacquired person), assuming that there will not be a value ascribed in thepurchase agreement to the LLC 1 equity that Entity X (or its affiliate) willreceive in consideration for the mergers, the acquisition price for the mergersis undetermined. Therefore, size-of-transaction should be the fair market valueof the equity of Targets A, B, and C (as determined by the board of Entity V).Should the pre-acquisition debt of Targets A, B, and C be taken into account indetermining the fair market value of their equity? (YES MV)

2-Under the alternate scenario, Entity X would be deemedto be the acquiring person. As the size-of-transaction is similarlyundetermined, the size-of-transaction will be the fair market value of theequity interests that Entity X will be acquiring in LLC 1 (as determined by theboard of Entity X) will be the pre-acquisition debt of LLC 1 be taken intoaccount in determining the fair market value of its equity (YES - MV)

3-Does the refinancing result in any adjustment to thesize-of-transaction?
(NO unless additional debt is taken on MV)

About Informal Interpretations

Informal interpretations provide guidance from previous staff interpretations on the applicability of the HSR rules to specific fact situations. You should not rely on them as a substitute for reading the Act and the Rules themselves. These materials do not, and are not intended to, constitute legal advice.

Learn more about Informal Interpretations.